CANONIST CALLS ‘PRIVATE MASS’ BLUFF – All Masses must be public
ROME (ChurchMilitant.com) – A Rome-based expert in canon law is calling time on the fiction of “private Masses” as a “nonsense” made up by bishops to justify the illegal banning of the faithful from participating in the Eucharist.
“The fact is that both theologically and canonically, there is no such thing as a private Mass. Strictly speaking, every Mass is public — because the offering of the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is the Catholic Church’s highest form of public worship, writes canonist Catherine Caridi, creator of the popular blog Canon Law Made Easy.
The faithful are being told repeatedly that “Masses are still being celebrated in church as usual; they just aren’t being celebrated publicly,” observes Dr. Caridi.
“This is, after all, how many bishops are phrasing the matter. They have told the faithful that ‘public acts of worship’ have been canceled.”
“If you sense that there is something about the wording of these sorts of statements that doesn’t feel theologically right, you’re on to something,” the canon law expert writes.
In an essay published Thursday, Caridi examines canon law, Vatican II, Church history and the Catechism of the Catholic Church, concluding that “the Church’s teaching on this point has always been consistent: By definition, every Mass is public.”
Slamming the novelty of digital Masses, the canonist points out that it is “nonsensical to claim, as many clergy are doing, that ‘when you watch a Mass via livestreaming, it’s the same as being present,’ and ‘Mass is being celebrated for everybody, it’s just that you now attend Mass virtually rather than physically.'”
“‘Attend’ means exactly what everyone has always known that it means, being physically rather than virtually present,” she insists.
Caridi, who holds a licentiate in Latin canon law and a doctorate in Eastern canon law, cites canon 837, which categorically states that “liturgical actions are not private actions” and because they, by “their nature entail a common celebration, they are to be celebrated with the presence and active participation of the Christian faithful where possible.”
She also cites canon 906, which emphasizes: “Except for a just and reasonable cause, a priest is not to celebrate the eucharistic Sacrifice without the participation of at least some member of the faithful.”
The canonist argues that the pandemic does not constitute a “just and reasonable cause” for a priest not celebrating Mass in the presence of the faithful, since historically the situation of nobody else being present when a priest is celebrating Mass has “always arisen because there simply is nobody else in the vicinity.”
“In other words, the problem arose only because the priest wanted/needed a congregation, and there just wasn’t anybody available!” Caridi stresses.
In fact, in the 1917 Code of Canon Law, when the traditional Latin Mass was the norm, then-canon 813.1 stated unequivocally that a priest could not celebrate Mass without the presence of a ‘minister’ who would serve the Mass and make the responses.
A woman was allowed to make the responses, even though she was not permitted to serve the Mass or come close to the altar, Caridi explains.
“For generations, the Church’s position was firm: If a priest wanted to offer Mass, there had to be at least one other person present. Otherwise … the Mass could not be celebrated, period,” she states, adding: “The 1917 code’s refusal even to permit a priest to offer Mass in the absence of a congregation was actually much more stringent than the 1983 code’s canon 906, which allows a priest to say Mass alone for a ‘just and reasonable cause.'”
Illustrating from the life of Blessed Charles de Foucauld (1858–1916), who was unable to offer Mass regularly because of his apostolate as a hermit in northern Africa and because he was surrounded mostly by non-Christians, Caridi narrates how the priest petitioned Pope St. Pius X for a dispensation that would permit him to say Mass alone and “without a phone or any regular means of receiving mail, waited in his solitude for a long time, agonizing at his inability to offer the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass.”
The holy priest finally received the news of his dispensation on Jan. 31, 1908. “In the 20th century, when the Church began to relax the restriction that prevented priests from saying Mass alone, it was this kind of situation that it had in mind,” Caridi reasons, summing up:
The allowance for a priest to say Mass alone ‘for a just and reasonable cause,’ found in the current canon 906, was never, ever in a million years meant to suggest that priests could celebrate Mass alone because they barred the faithful from attending Mass, when they were right there in the vicinity and wished devoutly to be present at the celebration!
The author of Making Martyrs East and West: Canonization in the Catholic and Russian Orthodox Churches concedes that churches can take appropriate precautions, such as sitting far apart, “but in the nearly 2,000-year history of the Catholic Church, no physical illness has ever theologically or canonically superseded the faithful’s spiritual well-being.”
Caridi notes legitimate instances of a priest celebrating Mass by himself, e.g. if a priest is traveling and says Mass in his hotel room.
Theologically, this does not mean that his Mass is “private,” but “his Mass will end up being said all alone, simply because the general public is rightly unable to wander in and out of other people’s hotel rooms.”
Conversely, if a priest is saying Mass by himself in an open place other than a church, and people do happen to see him doing so and want to join him, they cannot be forbidden to do so, Caridi clarifies — as might happen on an empty dining room on a cruise ship.
“It’s time to stop playing word games, and acknowledge that words like ‘public’ and ‘private’ and … ‘it’s for your good,’ have not suddenly acquired new definitions that they never had before,” the canonist concludes, recalling Jesus’ warning: “Let your ‘Yes’ mean ‘Yes’ and your ‘No’ mean ‘No.’ Anything more is from the Evil One.”
Read the source: https://www.churchmilitant.com/news/article/canonist-calls-private-mass-bluff
Related Articles click below:
IDAHO BISHOP BANS MASS ‘AD ORIENTEM’: Bishop Peter Christensen’s order comes amid rapid expansion of Traditional Latin Mass http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2020/03/31/idaho-bishop-bans-mass-ad-orientem-bishop-peter-christensens-order-comes-amid-rapid-expansion-of-traditional-latin-mass/
The Gift of the Liturgical Reform http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2020/01/19/the-gift-of-the-liturgical-reform/
Etiquette at Mass: Reasonable Do’s and Don’ts for Polite and Proper Worship http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2019/10/30/etiquette-at-mass-reasonable-dos-and-donts-for-polite-and-proper-worship/
Liturgical Dance & Cardinal Arinze, Prefect for the Congregation of Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2019/07/31/liturgical-dance-cardinal-arinze-prefect-for-the-congregation-of-divine-worship-and-the-discipline-of-the-sacraments/
Eight Ways to the Sacred Liturgy http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2019/06/16/eight-ways-to–the-sacred-liturgy/
CARDINAL GERHARD MÜLLER: PRIESTS ‘DUTY-BOUND’ TO RESIST BISHOPS DEMANDING PROTESTANT COMMUNION http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2018/12/13/cardinal-gerhard-muller-priests-duty-bound-to-resist-bishops-demanding-protestant-communion/
What Vatican II said—and didn’t say—about the liturgy http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2018/12/06/what-vatican-ii-said-and-didnt-say-about-the-liturgy/
CARDINAL GERHARD MÜLLER SLAMS ROME OVER INTERCOMMUNION: Warns Communion for non-Catholics ‘absolutely, objectively’ impossible http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2018/07/24/cardinal-gerhard-muller-slams-rome-over-intercommunion-warns-communion-for-non-catholics-absolutely-objectively-impossible/
GERMAN PRIESTS RESIST ARCHBISHOP HANS-JOSEF BECKER OVER INTERCOMMUNION WITH NON-CATHOLICS http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2018/07/05/german-priests-resist-archbishop-hans-josef-becker-over-intercommunion-with-non-catholics/
POPE FRANCIS: VATICAN ‘NOT PUTTING THE BRAKES ON’ INTERCOMMUNION http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2018/06/22/pope-francis-vatican-not-putting-the-brakes-on-intercommunion/
VATICAN NIXES INTERCOMMUNION: Pope Francis halts German push for Protestant intercommunion http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2018/06/07/vatican-nixes-intercommunion-pope-francis-halts-german-push-for-protestant-intercommunion/
CARDINAL FRANCIS ARINZE: STOP INTERCOMMUNION – Become Catholic to receive Holy Communion http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2018/05/25/cardinal-francis-arinze-stop-intercommunion-become-catholic-to-receive-holy-communion/
OREGON ARCHBISHOP ALEXANDER SAMPLE FIGHTS TO RESTORE EUCHARISTIC REVERENCE http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2018/05/17/oregon-archbishop-alexander-sample-fights-to-restore-eucharistic-reverence/
INTERCOMMUNION CLASH PITS BISHOP AGAINST BISHOP http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2018/05/16/intercommunion-clash-pits-bishop-against-bishop/
CARDINAL WILLEM EIJK: INTERCOMMUNION RESPONSE ‘INCOMPREHENSIBLE’ – Dutch prelate blasts German plan for Protestant communion http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2018/05/14/cardinal-willem-eijk-intercommunion-response-incomprehensible-dutch-prelate-blasts-german-plan-for-protestant-communion/
Seven German Bishops: Cardinal Rainer Woelki of Cologne and six other bishops Ask Vatican to Block Intercommunion Proposal http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2018/04/05/seven-german-bishops-cardinal-rainer-woelki-of-cologne-and-six-other-bishops-ask-vatican-to-block-intercommunion-proposal/
Cardinal Robert Sarah: Many Church leaders ‘underestimate the serious crisis that the Church is going through’ http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2018/04/05/cardinal-robert-sarah-many-church-leaders-underestimate-the-serious-crisis-that-the-church-is-going-through/
Cardinal Robert Sarah Confirms Vatican Retains Last Word on Translations http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2017/10/15/cardinal-robert-sarah-confirms-vatican-retains-last-word-on-translations/
CARDINAL RAYMOND BURKE BACKS CARDINAL ROBERT SARAH’S LITURGICAL REFORMS http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2017/09/27/cardinal-raymond-burke-backs-cardinal-robert-sarahs-liturgical-reforms/
POPE BENEDICT XVI: POPES CAN’T SCRAP LITURGY http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2017/09/12/pope-benedict-xvi-popes-cant-scrap-liturgy/
Why Ad Orientem Mass is Anathema to So Many? http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2017/08/13/why-ad-orientem-mass-is-anathema-to-so-many/
Three Liturgical Changes We Need Now http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/01/21/three-liturgical-changes-we-need-now/
The Pope Francis modifies the rite of Holy Thursday and permits women to also participate http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/01/21/the-pope-francis-modifies-the-rite-of-holy-thursday-and-permits-women-to-also-participate/
Cardinal Sarah: Priests Don’t Have to Wash Women’s Feet on Holy Thursday – Clarification comes after priests voice concerns about recent liturgical innovation http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/16/cardinal-sarah-priests-dont-have-to-wash-womens-feet-on-holy-thursday-clarification-comes-after-priests-voice-concerns-about-recent-liturgical-innovation/
Pope Francis ‘angry’ over media slant on women deacons http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/06/29/pope-francis-angry-over-media-slant-on-women-deacons/
Pope Francis: “On women priests, that cannot be done”
Women Priests and Married Priests: What’s the difference?
Should Women Preach at Mass? http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/04/should-women-preach-at-mass/
“Women Priests” are living a lie
Girls Should Not Be “Altar Servers” http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2015/12/21/girls-should-not-be-altar-servers/
On the Ordination of Women and the Priesthood of Christ
How Pope John Paul II restored liturgical sanity?
The Golden Calf and Our Catholic Mass: 3 Reasons Man Cannot Invent the Liturgy
THE DOWNLOAD—LITURGY OF MAN: Fabricated liturgy isn’t from Vatican II but came from many sources after the Council http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/15/the-download-liturgy-of-man-fabricated-liturgy-isnt-from-vatican-ii-but-came-from-many-sources-after-the-council/
Are You Afflicted with Father Freelance? – Liturgical Abuse http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/01/14/are-you-afflicted-with-father-freelance-liturgical-abuse/
WHY DO YOU WANT TO BE A PRIEST? http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/10/why-do-you-want-to-be-a-priest/
Cardinal Sarah: More Christ, less ‘worldly entertainment’ at Mass, says Vatican Head of Worship
The Lord’s Prayer During Mass: Should We Hold Hands? Or Raise Them in the Air?
Are you doing this at Mass? Stop that!
Why we should neither add to nor subtract from the Liturgy?
The Sacred Liturgy as a Monument or Witness of Tradition http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2017/09/10/the-sacred-liturgy-as-a-monument-or-witness-of-tradition/
CARDINAL ROBERT SARAH: PRIESTS SHOULD FACE EAST AND COMMUNICANTS SHOULD KNEEL http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/07/06/cardinal-robert-sarah-priests-should-face-east-and-communicants-should-kneel/
On Facing East During Mass http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/07/14/on-facing-east-during-mass/
FR GEORGE RUTLER ON AD ORIENTEM http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/07/20/fr-george-rutler-on-ad-orientem/
CARDINAL ROBERT SARAH: SILENCE IN LITURGY NECESSARY http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/02/03/cardinal-robert-sarah-silence-in-liturgy-necessary/
Women Priests and Married Priests: What’s the difference?
‘Priestess’ Sacrilege Shutdown
Bishop orders halt of 5 liturgical abuses
Bishop Schneider: We are in the 4th great crisis of the Church
Bishop Schneider: Crisis in the Church – Confusion & Relativism, etc.
Bishop Scheider: Battling the new Gnosticism within the Church
Bishop Schneider unloads the coming persecution in the West
Bishop Athanasius Schneider on communion in the hand
Bishop Schneider slams liturgical abuse & stand up for traditional Catholics
Communion in the hand, Part 1-2: Experimentation & Explanation
Breaking: Another bishop prohibits communion in the hand
PARISHIONERS FORBIDDEN COMMUNION ON TONGUE FOR FEAR OF FLU http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/07/parishioners-forbidden-communion-on-tongue-for-fear-of-flu/
THE VORTEX: NO COMMUNION IN THE HAND – Get on your knees and receive your King http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/09/the-vortex-no-communion-in-the-hand-get-on-your-knees-and-receive-your-king/
CBCP: On the Question of Kneeling or Standing After the Consecration Until After the Great AMEN During the Eucharistic Celebration http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/22/on-the-question-of-kneeling-or-standing-after-the-consecration-until-after-the-great-amen-during-the-eucharistic-celebration/
The Truth About Communion in the Hand While Standing
Cardinal Arinze on kneeling for communion, kneelers & altar girls
Faith of our Fathers: Mass Confusion – Altar Rails – Right Track or Wrong Track
Fr. Robert Barron & Dr. Scott Hahn on Biblical Interpretation and the Liturgy
Kneeling Ban: Good Liturgy or Loss of Religious Freedom
Should women be lectors at Mass?
Full participation at Mass: How do I do that?
Mass Etiquette: 20 Things to do and not to do in Mass
Dressing Respectfully for Mass
The Meaning of Mass by Archbishop Fulton Sheen
WATCH THE FULL SHOW: ‘THE DOWNLOAD—TRADITION UNDER FIRE’ http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/01/29/watch-the-full-show-the-download-tradition-under-fire/
What are the historical roots of the Mass?, etc.
Liturgical Abuses at Mass: What to DO? http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/06/liturgical-abuses-at-mass-what-to-do/
THE DOWNLOAD—MIXING THE SACRED AND THE PROFANE: The St. Cecilia Cathedral has several times hosted exhibits with secular and even pagan displays http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/15/the-download-mixing-the-sacred-and-the-profane-the-st-cecilia-cathedral-has-several-times-hosted-exhibits-with-secular-and-even-pagan-displays/
WATCH THE FULL SHOW: ‘THE DOWNLOAD—THE ABUSE OF ‘EUCHARISTIC MINISTERS’’ http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/06/17/watch-the-full-show-the-download-the-abuse-of-eucharistic-ministers/
The Origin of Catholic Mass and Structure
The Mass, Our Salvific Sacrifice to Avoid Hell and Achieve Salvation
WATCH THE FULL SHOW: ‘THE DOWNLOAD—COMMUNION FOR LUTHERANS?’ http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/02/12/watch-the-full-show-the-download-communion-for-lutherans/
WATCH THE FULL SHOW: ‘THE DOWNLOAD—RESTORING THE LITURGY’ http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/07/08/watch-the-full-show-the-download-restoring-the-liturgy/
Mic’d Up – The Black Mass Homosexual Generation
Bishop Slattery: Countering with Prayer the Proposed Black Mass in Oklahoma City
Ugly Churches and the Dictatorship of Populism http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/04/ugly-churches-and-the-dictatorship-of-populism/
PHONY CATHOLICISM http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2017/07/02/phony-catholicism/
CIA: Weapons of Mass Destruction, Part 1-2
In summary, the beauty of the liturgy has great power and can be utilized by catechists, both to teach others about the divine mystery hidden in the liturgy as well as to foster beautiful encounters with God in Holy Mass and other liturgical events. However, its beauty can never be divorced from the truth, lest it be worshipped for its own sake.