Must Catholics Believe that Islam Is Peaceful?

Must Catholics Believe that Islam Is Peaceful?

Head In Sand

The Apostles’ Creed (updated version):

I believe in the Holy Spirit, the Holy Catholic Church, the communion of Saints, the forgiveness of sins, and the peaceful nature of Islam. Amen.

Or, anyway, that’s how it ought to read according to Monsignor Stuart Swetland, President of Donnelly College in Kansas City. No, Msgr. Swetland didn’t actually propose a revision to the Apostles’ Creed, but he does seem to be saying that Catholics have a religious obligation to affirm that Islam is a religion of peace.

In a long statement following up on a radio debate with Robert Spencer on Relevant Radio’s Drew Mariani Show, Swetland, according to Spencer, “contends that the statements of recent Popes to the effect that Islam is a religion of peace fall into the category of teachings to which Catholics must give ‘religious assent.’”

Swetland writes: “My main purpose in having a discussion with Robert Spencer, a Catholic, on a Catholic radio network was to show clearly that his positions on Islam were at odds with Catholic teaching.” He goes on to give a sample of magisterial teachings on Islam, starting with Nostra Aetate and including statements and exhortations from Paul VI, John Paul II, Benedict XVI, and Francis. He then observes:

Robert Spencer’s positions seem to be at odds with the magisterial teachings on what authentic Islam is and what Catholics are called to do about it (accept immigrants, avoid hateful generalizations, show esteem and respect, etc.). At least in the area of morals, Robert seems to be a dissenter from the papal magisterium.

And Fr. Swetland is a dissenter from common sense. The pages of history, the daily news, and Islam’s sacred texts all attest to the fact that Islam is not a religion of peace. Or, to quote the Ayatollah Khomeini, “Those who know nothing of Islam pretend that Islam counsels against war. Those are witless.” Khomeini was an Ayatollah Usma, a “Grand Sign of God”—an honor bestowed only on the most learned religious leaders. My guess is that the Ayatollah knew a lot more about Islam than Msgr. Swetland does.

I’m not saying that Swetland is “witless.” In fact, he seems to be an intelligent man. He has an undergraduate degree in physics, was a Rhodes Scholar, and studied philosophy and economics at Oxford. Still, high IQ and common sense don’t always go together. As George Orwell noted, “some ideas are so stupid that only intellectuals believe them.”

In the radio debate and in an article responding to his statement, Robert Spencer does a fine job of dismantling Swetland’s arguments. For one thing, says Spencer, affirmations about the nature of Islam should not be a matter of Catholic faith and morals. In other words, it’s a serious overreach to contend that the “wrong” opinion on the nature of Islam or on the advisability of mass Muslim immigration may constitute dissent from Church teaching. In saying that it does, Swetland has just created a whole new class of Catholic dissenters—one that probably numbers in the tens of millions. Spencer also observes that what previous popes had to say about Islam contradicts what current popes have said. Which Roman Pontiff must Catholics agree with: “Pope Francis, who declared that ‘authentic Islam and the proper reading of the Koran are opposed to every form of violence,’ or Pope Callixtus III, who in 1455 vowed to ‘exalt the true Faith, and to extirpate the diabolical sect of the reprobate and faithless Mahomet in the East’?”

The linchpin of Swetland’s case is Nostra Aetate’s brief statement about the “Moslems.” But as Spencer, and I, and others have pointed out, there are numerous problems withNostra Aetate. One question that arises is whether Nostra Aetate was ever intended to be a dogmatic statement. That’s more of a question for Church historians to debate, but let’s just say for now that the question is debatable. What is less debatable is that the section of Nostra Aetate that deals with the “Moslems” is highly problematic, highly selective, and poorly thought out. For instance, the document states (I’m using Swetland’s translation) that Muslims “venerate Jesus,” but to anyone familiar with the Muslim Jesus, it’s not at all clear that it’s the same Jesus. For one thing, the Muslim Jesus makes his appearance in the Koran for no other purpose than to refute everything that Jesus of Nazareth says about himself. Nostra Aetate goes on to say that “they [Muslims] await the day of judgment and the reward of God following the resurrection of the dead.” What the document fails to say is that on the day of judgment, according to Islamic teaching, all non-Muslims will be cast into hell. As to the “reward of God”? Well, let’s just say that it’s not the same reward that Catholics await. Here’s a typical description from the Koran:

As for the righteous, they shall surely triumph. Theirs shall be gardens and vineyards, and high-bosomed maidens for companions (78: 31-34).

There are many other omissions in Nostra Aetate. In fact, it seems to have been designed to present only a positive view of Islam. I’m not the only one to have noticed this skewed presentation. In a 2012 essay for L’Osservatore Romano, Pope Benedictwrites of a “weakness” in Nostra Aetate. “It speaks of religion solely in a positive way,” he said, “and it disregards the sick and distorted forms of religion.” Sick and distorted? Benedict doesn’t speak explicitly of Islam, but exactly what other religion so readily lends itself to sick and distorted interpretations? The trouble with Nostra Aetate is that it leaves us with a very incomplete picture of Islam. The picture has enough holes to drive a fleet of suicide truck bombs through it.

The main problem with Msgr. Swetland’s statement, however, is its recklessness. Last week in Crisis I wrote that the Church’s handling of the Islamic challenge may prove to be far more scandalous than its handling of the sex abuse crisis. Church authorities are engaged in what amounts to a cover-up of Islam’s aggressive nature, and Msgr. Swetland is a prime example of this ecclesiastical determination to put a positive spin on everything Islamic. But the stakes involved in doing so are extremely high. As I wrotelast week, “as the gap widens between what Church officials say about Islam and what ordinary Catholics can see with their own eyes, the credibility of the Church may once again come into question as it did during the sex abuse scandals.”

Spencer makes the same point, albeit a bit more boldly: “if Monsignor Swetland is correct, then Catholics must affirm that Islam is a religion of peace…and the Catholic Church will be requiring that its faithful affirm the truth of what is an obvious and egregious falsehood.” By binding themselves to this falsehood, says Spencer, Catholic leaders will undermine their authority to speak in the name of Christ.

Msgr. Swetland worries that Spencer’s interpretation will drive moderate Muslims into the arms of the radicals. What he should be worried about is that his own (and Pope Francis’) interpretation will drive common-sense Catholics out of the Church. Does he really want to stake the Church’s authority on such a slender reed as a single section ofNostra Aetate and a few scattered papal statements? At a moment in recent history when it’s becoming clear to all but the most obtuse that Islam is not a religion of peace, is this the time for doubling down on a claim that flies in the face of all the evidence? Do Msgr. Swetland and other like-minded clerics want the Church to stand or fall on this fantasy view of Islam?

It can be reasonably argued that Church leaders should maintain a prudent silence about Islam’s aggressive nature lest Christians be killed in retaliation. But that is not the same thing as loudly and deceptively proclaiming that Islam is something that it is not—namely, a peaceful religion not unlike Christianity. Monsignor Swetland says Catholics should “show esteem and respect” for Muslims. But where is the respect for Catholics? In asking Catholics to be submissively content with dangerously misleading views on Islam, Swetland betrays a low level of respect for the intelligence of ordinary Catholics.

When the Apostles’ Creed was first set down in writing, Christians didn’t know anything about Islam. It had yet to be invented. But one thing that early Christians did know is that they were supposed to be on the lookout for false prophets. Nowadays, however, for a certain kind of Christian with a certain kind of mindset, there are no false prophets or false religions. Since they don’t admit of false prophets or wolves in sheep’s clothing, those are the kind of Christians who are most likely to welcome the wolves into the sheepfold.

Read the source and comments: http://www.crisismagazine.com/2016/must-catholics-believe-islam-peaceful

William Kilpatrick

By

William Kilpatrick taught for many years at Boston College. He is the author of several books about cultural and religious issues, includingPsychological Seduction; Why Johnny Can’t Tell Right From Wrong; and Christianity, Islam and Atheism: The Struggle for the Soul of the West and the forthcoming The Politically Incorrect Guide to Jihad. His articles have appeared in numerous publications, including Catholic World Report, National Catholic Register, Aleteia, Saint Austin Review, Investor’s Business Daily, and First Things. His work is supported in part by the Shillman Foundation. For more on his work and writings, visit his website, turningpointproject.com

Related Articles/ Videos click below:

ISLAM 101 – A Crash Course 

Please click this link to read the Article on Islam 101 – A Crash Course

Was Muhammad a False Prophet? http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/02/17/was-muhammad-a-false-prophet/

Islam as a Christian Heresy: 8 Quotes from St. John Damascene A.D. 749

What did the Saints say about Islam?

Jesuit Manuel Carreira: “Islam, the Worst Plague the Human Race Has Ever Seen” http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/04/27/jesuit-manuel-carreira-islam-the-worst-plague-the-human-race-has-ever-seen/

The truth about Islam: An interview with Brigitte Gabriel

The Truth about Islam: Islam is a violent, intolerant religion

David Barton: Despite Obama’s rhetoric, Islam is NOT a religion of peace http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/22/david-barton-despite-obamas-rhetoric-islam-is-not-a-religion-of-peace/

SHARIA LAW IN ACTION: ISIS Stones Couple To Death, Executes 8 And Crucifies Bodies…”Religion of Peace”? http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/04/05/sharia-law-in-action-isis-stones-couple-to-death-executes-8-and-crucifies-bodiesreligion-of-peace/

President Barack Obama: To Stop Terrorism Islam Must Reconcile Itself To Modernity http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/04/05/president-barack-obama-to-stop-terrorism-islam-must-reconcile-itself-to-modernity/

‘Islam Is ISIS. Whoever Says Otherwise Is a Liar,’ Nun Says http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/01/06/islam-is-isis-whoever-says-otherwise-is-a-liar-nun-says/

Islam Means Submission: Dominance and Submission in Cologne and the Persian Gulf http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/01/19/islam-means-submission-dominance-and-submission-in-cologne-and-the-persian-gulf/

Major Muslim Leader Makes This Message To All Christians: “If You Refuse To Convert To Islam, Then The Only Thing Between You And Us Is The Sword” http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/08/03/major-muslim-leader-makes-this-message-to-all-christians-if-you-refuse-to-convert-to-islam-then-the-only-thing-between-you-and-us-is-the-sword/

Breitbart News Callers …. Discover Islam Not Religion of Peace

Muslims fail to prove Islam is a religion of peace in debate

The Pyramid of Hate in the Muslim World

Should we call it “Radical Islam”?

Is Islam a Heresy or World Religion? Legos and Muhammad

Why Thomas Aquinas Distrusted Islam? http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2015/12/28/why-thomas-aquinas-distrusted-islam/

HE WARNED US ABOUT ISLAM 750 YEARS AGO – AND HIS WARNING IS STILL RELEVANT TODAY http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/05/26/he-warned-us-about-islam-750-years-ago-and-his-warning-is-still-relevant-today/

Blasphemy Laws of Pakistan: Symbols of Islamic Fanaticism http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/09/blasphemy-laws-of-pakistan-symbols-of-islamic-fanaticism/

What Does Islam Teach About… Deception, Lying and Taqiyya http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/08/08/what-does-islam-teach-about-deception-lying-and-taqiyya/

Islam’s Religious Exemption from Criticism

Jesus in Islam: Why Islam is false (Video)?

Former Muslim Apologist Explains Divinity of Jesus http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2015/12/11/former-muslim-apologist-explains-divinity-of-jesus/

Solidarity with Islam? http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/01/26/solidarity-with-islam/

Migration and the Islamization of Europe

Beautiful woman who was raped exposes 1 vital truth about Islam

Muslim Imam Defends Refugee Sexual Assaults With 8 Outrageous Words http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/01/22/muslim-imam-defends-refugee-sexual-assaults-with-8-outrageous-words/

Ex-Muslim Author: ‘Sharia is with us and it’s women who suffer’

Cardinal Robert Sarah: ISIS and Gender Ideology are like apocalyptic beasts

Synod on the Family also looks into persecution of families by ISIS

Analysis: Christians oppressed for their faith by the Islamic Groups

Only Way to Stop Islamic Terrorism is by Banning Islam

A Monastic Response to Violent Islam

Japan shut down radical Islam entirely…Here’s the simple way they did it.

Shock: The grand lesson of the Paris Jihad

Italian Cardinal Angelo Bagnasco calls on Muslims to publicly condemn ISIS

Paris after the ISIS attacks (Video) & Pope Francis’ Message

At Grand Mosque in Central African Republic, Pope Francis denounces violence perpetrated in the name of religion or God

Islam and French Politics: A Reflection http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/05/15/islam-and-french-politics-a-reflection/

The Greatest Murder Machine in History http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/06/07/the-greatest-murder-machine-in-history/

Islam, Revolution, and Black Lives Matter http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/07/14/islam-revolution-and-black-lives-matter/

ISLAM IS NOT A CONSTITUTIONALLY PROTECTED RELIGION. HERE’S WHY?

Islam is not a Constitutionally Protected Religion… Here’s why?

Please click this link to read the Article on Islam is not a Constitutionally Protected Religion. Here’s why?

No Exit (from Islam) http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/06/29/no-exit-from-islam/

5 Reasons The Qur’an Can Never Co-Exist with the Constitution

Please click this link to read the Article on 5 Reasons the Qur’an can never co-exist with the Constitution

Is Sharia Islamic Law Compatible with the American Constitution?

The top 10 Koran verses that will help you understand ISIS better 

Please click this link to watch the video on Top 10 Koran verses that will help you understand ISIS better

24 Reasons ISIS are wrong: Muslim scholars blast Islamic State

Please click this link to read the article on 24 Reasons ISIS are wrong: Muslim scholars blast Islamic State

Muslims vs. ‘Outlaws of Islam’: Islamic Voices Lead Fight Against Extremists http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/23/muslims-vs-outlaws-of-islam-islamic-voices-lead-fight-against-extremists/

Report: Only Word for ISIS Atrocities Is Genocide http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/12/report-only-word-for-isis-atrocities-is-genocide/

How You Can Help Stop the Christian Genocide by the ISIS? http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/03/13/how-you-can-help-stop-the-christian-genocide-by-the-isis/

ISIS turns Muslim theological tradition on its head: ISIS deviates from mainstream Islam by rejecting scholarly interpretation and religious pluralism http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/02/17/isis-turns-muslim-theological-tradition-on-its-head-isis-deviates-from-mainstream-islam-by-rejecting-scholarly-interpretation-and-religious-pluralism/

Saints’ bones among rubble of Syrian monastery destroyed by Isil http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/04/07/saints-bones-among-rubble-of-syrian-monastery-destroyed-by-isil/

ISIS CHILD EXECUTIONS, TORTURES ROCK SYRIA http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/05/12/isis-child-executions-tortures-rock-syria/

Syriac Catholic Patriarch Younan Warns: Western Politicians and Media Mislead World on Middle East http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/07/22/syriac-catholic-patriarch-younan-warns-western-politicians-and-media-mislead-world-on-middle-east/

Bishop Antoine Chbeir Cries Out as ISIS Devastates Syrian Towns http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/05/25/bishop-antoine-chbeir-cries-out-as-isis-devastates-syrian-towns/

‘Forgive ISIS’: Girl’s dying request to mother after she is burnt alive by militants in her own home http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/06/16/forgive-isis-girls-dying-request-to-mother-after-she-is-burnt-alive-by-militants-in-her-own-home/

Islam in Crisis – The Decline of Islam is Real http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/06/23/islam-in-crisis-the-decline-of-islam-is-real/

What’s ISIS? It’s Islam Repeating History. Is Islam a Danger to the Religious Freedom of the U.S. and the World? http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/07/04/whats-isis-its-islam-repeating-history-is-islam-a-danger-to-the-religious-freedom-of-the-u-s-and-the-world/

When Islamists and Secularists Agree… http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/07/04/when-islamists-and-secularists-agree/

VATICAN REACTS WITH HORROR AT FRENCH PRIEST FR. JACQUES HAMEL MARTYRED BY ISIS MILITANTS http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/07/26/vatican-reacts-with-horror-at-french-priest-fr-jacques-hamel-martyred-by-isis-militants/

ISLAMIC STATE ANSWERS POPE FRANCIS: OURS IS A RELIGIOUS WAR AND WE HATE YOU http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/08/02/islamic-state-answers-pope-francis-ours-is-a-religious-war-and-we-hate-you/

ISIS Rejects Pope’s Interpretation of Their Own Religion http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/08/03/isis-rejects-popes-interpretation-of-their-own-religion/

BY ISIS http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/08/05/chaldean-patriarch-louis-sako-recounts-christian-persecution-by-isis/

NEW BOKO HARAM LEADER SAYS HE’LL KILL MORE CHRISTIANS, DESTROY CHURCHES http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/08/05/new-boko-haram-leader-says-hell-kill-more-christians-destroy-churches/

ISIS CLAIMS RESPONSIBILITY FOR BELGIAN MACHETE ATTACK http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/08/09/isis-claims-responsibility-for-belgian-machete-attack/

What is the Islamic State? What ISIS really wants?

ISIS’s Anti-Islamic Theology of Rape

Is sex slavery sanctioned in Islam?

 Muslim Activist Says This is Why Islamism is ‘Much More Dangerous Than Nazism’

ISIS Desecrates Saint’s Remains, Bulldozes Monastery – Priest Still Missing

High-Profile Rome Exorcist: ISIS is Satan

German Cardinal Kurt Koch: ISIS is a ‘Satanic Terrorist Group’

UK Cardinal Vincent Nichols: Terrorist need to be stopped – Encouraging use of force against ISIS

A Muslim US President?

Needed: A New Church Policy Toward Islam Part 1

Please click this link to read the Article on Needed: A New Church Policy Toward Islam Part 1

Needed: A New Church Policy Toward Islam Part 2

Please click this link to read the Article Needed: A New Church Policy Toward Islam Part 2

Needed: A New Church Policy Toward Islam Part 3

Please click this link to the Article on Needed: A New Church Policy Toward Islam Part 3

Pope Benedict XVI was right in warning about radical Islam

Does Fr. Dwight Longenecker teach what the Church teaches on Catholic-Muslim relations?

ISSIS is the Result of Christians “Growing Flaccid in Virtue and Ignorant of its Own Moral Foundations.” http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/08/01/issis-is-the-result-of-christians-growing-flaccid-in-virtue-and-ignorant-of-its-own-moral-foundations/

Pope Francis Condemns ‘Homicidal Folly and Senseless Hatred’ in Orlando, Florida, USA http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/06/13/pope-francis-condemns-homicidal-folly-and-senseless-hatred-in-orlando-florida-usa/

NIGERIA: AMONG MOST NEGLECTED HUMANITARIAN CRISES IN THE WORLD http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/06/14/nigeria-among-most-neglected-humanitarian-crises-in-the-world/

CARDINAL RAYMOND BURKE: ‘ISLAM WANTS TO GOVERN THE WORLD’ http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/07/26/cardinal-raymond-burke-islam-wants-to-govern-the-world/

What The Media And The Church Are Not Telling You As To Why Muslims Beheaded A French Catholic Priest http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/07/27/what-the-media-and-the-church-are-not-telling-you-as-to-why-muslims-beheaded-a-french-catholic-priest/

CIA: The Crusades against Muslim Aggression 

Please click this link to watch the video on CIA: The Crusades against Muslim Aggression

The Crusades Were a Reasonable Response to Unchecked Islamic Aggression http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/05/18/the-crusades-were-a-reasonable-response-to-unchecked-islamic-aggression/

The Real History of the Crusades

The Real History of the Crusades – To set the record straight

http://www.crisismagazine.com/2011/the-real-history-of-the-crusades

Four Myths about the Crusades 

4 Myths about the Crusades: In light of beheadings…

Please click this link to read about the Four Myths about the Crusades

ISIS (Islamic State) Flogs the Crusades Myth

Muslim Crusades Started Four Centuries Before the Western Crusades 

Please click this link to read the Article on Muslim Crusades Started Four Centuries Before Western Crusades

Crash Course on the Crusades

Please click this link to read the Article on Crash Course on the Crusades

The Crusades: A Response to Islamic Jihad http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/04/07/the-crusades-a-response-to-islamic-jihad/

Jihad vs Crusades by Bill Warner, PhD

Please click this link to watch the video on Jihad vs Crusades by Bill Warner, PhD

There’s Zero Equivalence Between the Crusades and Muslim Jihad

CIA: The Inquisition during the Medieval, Spanish and Roman Times

Please click this link to watch the video on CIA: The Inquisition during the Medieval, Spanish and Roman Times

Spanish Inquisition was 99% Myth. (BBC) http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/06/22/spanish-inquisition-was-99-myth-bbc/

Obama Compares Catholic Crusades to Islamic ISIS

Please click this link to watch the video on Obama compares Catholic Crusades to Islamic ISIS

Obama at Prayer Breakfast Affirms right to be godless

Please click this link to watch the video on Obama at Prayer Breakfast affirms right to be godless

Watch how Judge Jeanine Just Revealed the Moment She Understood on Obama’s Dark Secret 

Please click this link to watch the video on Judge Jeanine on Obama’s Dark Secret

Forged by War: The Three Battles in the Rise of the Rosary

Please click this link to read the Article on Forged by War: The three battles in the rise of the Rosary

A President, His Muslim Faith, And His Quran… Is It Ok For Him To Lie?

A President, his Muslim Faith and his Quran… Is it Ok for him to lie?

Proclaiming The Gospel in Lebanon: The Mohammad Yamout story http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/05/14/proclaiming-the-gospel-in-lebanon-the-mohammad-yamout-story/

Mario Joseph Testimony , a Muslim Imam Convert to Catholic Church  

Please click this link to watch the video on Mario Joseph Testimony, a Muslim Imam Convert to Catholic Church

Daniel Ali: Muslim Convert to Catholic Christianity

Malaysia Rules Muslim Man Can Convert to Christianity http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2016/06/20/malaysia-rules-muslim-man-can-convert-to-christianity/

Muslim Woman Gives Jesus One Week To Prove Himself Before Ending Her Life http://www.pagadiandiocese.org/2015/12/18/19410/

From Darkness to Light
As a Muslim imam, Mario Joseph was well-versed in the Koran and in the teachings of the Islamic religion. In fact, it was precisely the Koran that brought him to an encounter with Jesus Christ and with the truth of the Catholic faith. But his conversion did not come without difficulties; as a consequence, he has undergone grave persecution. How has he attained his intense love toward the Church, the Cross and Heaven? He himself tells us in this week’s impacting episode of Changing Tracks.