No Exit (from Islam)

No Exit (from Islam)

Woman in Mosque

The world is abuzz with talk of Brexit—the British vote to leave the European Union. Britain’s reclamation of its independence is now prompting talk that other nations might exit the EU—the Netherlands, Denmark, Greece, Italy, and a dozen more. Over on this side of the Atlantic, the Brexit initiative has renewed discussion about the U.S. exiting the UN.

What you won’t hear about is any discussion of Exslam—exiting Islam. No one seems to want to suggest that it might be a good idea for Muslims to consider leaving Islam. That’s curious because Islam figures prominently in the Brexit decision. It’s no secret that the chief catalyst for Brexit is Muslim immigration. It’s for the same reason that numerous other Europeans want out of the EU. Their countries are being Islamized before their eyes and there seems little they can do about it as long as policies on borders and immigration are set by bureaucrats in Brussels. The move to leave the EU is, in large part, a move to keep Islam out of Europe.

Which prompts a question. Why not encourage Muslims to leave Islam? Islam is not only a major problem for the rest of the world, it is also a major problem for many Muslims. How many? It’s difficult to say because expressing dissatisfaction with Islam is not something that Muslims are free to do. Criticism of Islam or its prophet is a violation of sharia blasphemy laws and is punishable by prison and sometimes death.

One of the complaints of those in Britain and Europe who want to part company with the EU is that it has evolved into a soft totalitarianism—a milder version of the old Soviet Union. Indeed, it’s been suggested that one of the reasons the pre-Brexit polls were so far off the mark is that Brits are afraid to tell pollsters what the really think for fear that Big Brother will be listening in on the phone conversation.

If the EU is a soft totalitarianism, then Islam is a hard form of the same. It suppresses dissent more effectively than the EU could ever hope to do. It is arguably as oppressive as the Nazi regime in Germany and the Communist dictatorship in the Soviet Union.

The chief evidence for this totalitarianism are the blasphemy laws and the apostasy laws. The first make it a crime to criticize Islam, and the second make it a crime to leave Islam. The apostasy laws perform a function similar to the border walls and fences erected by the communists in Eastern Europe. Just as at the Berlin Wall kept East Berlin residents firmly within the communist camp, the apostasy laws keep Muslims inside Islam. Except that the apostasy wall is moveable. If you are a Muslim, it follows you wherever you go so that, wherever you are, any Muslim can execute the death sentence on you if you fail to remain faithful to the faith. Like Trotsky in Mexico, you are never completely safe from the reach of the purists.

Without the blasphemy laws, Muslims would be free to criticize Islam, and without the apostasy laws, many would leave it. How many? Again, it’s difficult to say. But as Yusuf al-Qaradawi, perhaps the most influential cleric in the Muslim world, once put it, “if they [Muslims] had gotten rid of the punishment for apostasy, Islam would not exist today.” Coming as it does from a true believer, that is a fairly frank admission of the totalitarian nature of Islam.

Islam is a religion that is held together by force. Western societies profess to be opposed to such constraints on freedom of religion. In other matters, we are quick to say that people should free themselves from such oppression. Yet very few are willing to apply this principle to Islam.

The absence of any well-organized Exslam campaign can be explained in part by two basic misunderstandings about Islam. The first is a failure to understand that it is both a religion and a geo-political movement for world domination (James Bondish as that may sound). The second misunderstanding is to assume that, insofar as it is a religion, Islam is a religion just like ours. That would mean, of course, that it is a freely chosen religion. Therefore, if Muslims wanted to leave it, they would.

It’s true, of course, that converts to Islam have for the most part, freely chosen Islam. But once in, they are not so free to opt out. As for those who are born into Islam, they learn from the cradle that they must never think of leaving. Every year in the U.S. and in Europe, millions of Christians abandon the faith of their parents and choose some other faith or no faith at all. We mistakenly assume that Muslims are free to do likewise.

Another common mistake that skews our understanding of Islam is to assume that religion is a purely private affair between an individual and his God. Therefore we have no business trying to persuade people one way or another. That may be true of some rarefied versions of Western Christianity, but in most places and throughout most of history, religion was and is a very public matter. This is particularly the case with Islam, a religion which maintains that there are no private spaces—that every aspect of life must be governed by religious law.

Like Fr. Richard John Neuhaus, Islam believes there can be no such thing as a naked public square. Unlike him, it wants to take control of every public square in sight. You may think that religion is a purely private affair, but Muslims do not.

Islam is not a religion just like ours. Although some Muslims practice a peaceful (because diluted) version of it, it is at its core an aggressive, expansionist system. Consequently, it needs to be questioned and challenged. As Fr. James Schall, S.J.recently wrote:

I also think that Islam’s ideas and texts need directly to be confronted. They cannot be simply set aside and unexamined as too controversial to talk about, analyze, and criticize.

He argues that the current policy of only discussing things “about which everyone could agree” has been a failure. “It is what we do not agree with in Islam,” he says, “that needs to be talked about most.”

Because Islam is almost completely opposed to Western values, it makes sense, as Schall says, to confront its “ideas and texts.” It also makes sense to encourage Muslims to exit Islam.

Some “leave Islam” groups do exist. But the ex-Muslims who organize them don’t receive much support from Western governments which, by and large, have bought into the multicultural belief that cultural identities are set in stone and must not be changed. In addition, the leavers don’t seem to get much support from Western churches. Indeed, the Catholic Church seems to have adopted a policy of validating Islam as a member in good standing of the club of world religions. Although Catholic leaders agree that there is a problem with ISIS, many fail to see that the main problem with ISIS is its strict adherence to traditional Islam. Such naïveté among Western leaders does not provide much consolation to all those Muslims who, though they live outside ISIS-controlled territory, still live in virtual bondage to the same sharia system.

Eastern Europeans who chafed under communist rule at least had the reassurance of knowing that the West shared their opposition to Soviet ideology. But as long as the West continues in its Islam-is-just-fine mode, there will be little reason for Muslims to believe that anyone understands their plight, and thus little incentive to break free of the system. In their well-intentioned effort to be tolerant of all belief systems, naïve Westerners may be inadvertently helping to reinforce the prison bars.

Read the source and comments:

William Kilpatrick


William Kilpatrick taught for many years at Boston College. He is the author of several books about cultural and religious issues, includingPsychological Seduction; Why Johnny Can’t Tell Right From Wrong; and Christianity, Islam and Atheism: The Struggle for the Soul of the West. His articles have appeared in numerous publications, including Catholic World Report, National Catholic Register, Aleteia, Saint Austin Review, Investor’s Business Daily, and First Things. His work is supported in part by the Shillman Foundation. For more on his work and writings, visit his website,

Related Articles/ Videos click below:

ISLAM 101 – A Crash Course 

Please click this link to read the Article on Islam 101 – A Crash Course

Was Muhammad a False Prophet?

Islam as a Christian Heresy: 8 Quotes from St. John Damascene A.D. 749

What did the Saints say about Islam?

Jesuit Manuel Carreira: “Islam, the Worst Plague the Human Race Has Ever Seen”

The truth about Islam: An interview with Brigitte Gabriel

The Truth about Islam: Islam is a violent, intolerant religion

David Barton: Despite Obama’s rhetoric, Islam is NOT a religion of peace

SHARIA LAW IN ACTION: ISIS Stones Couple To Death, Executes 8 And Crucifies Bodies…”Religion of Peace”?

President Barack Obama: To Stop Terrorism Islam Must Reconcile Itself To Modernity

‘Islam Is ISIS. Whoever Says Otherwise Is a Liar,’ Nun Says

Islam Means Submission: Dominance and Submission in Cologne and the Persian Gulf

Breitbart News Callers …. Discover Islam Not Religion of Peace

Muslims fail to prove Islam is a religion of peace in debate

The Pyramid of Hate in the Muslim World

Should we call it “Radical Islam”?

Is Islam a Heresy or World Religion? Legos and Muhammad

Why Thomas Aquinas Distrusted Islam?


Blasphemy Laws of Pakistan: Symbols of Islamic Fanaticism

Islam’s Religious Exemption from Criticism

Jesus in Islam: Why Islam is false (Video)?

Former Muslim Apologist Explains Divinity of Jesus

Solidarity with Islam?

Migration and the Islamization of Europe

Beautiful woman who was raped exposes 1 vital truth about Islam

Muslim Imam Defends Refugee Sexual Assaults With 8 Outrageous Words

Ex-Muslim Author: ‘Sharia is with us and it’s women who suffer’

Cardinal Robert Sarah: ISIS and Gender Ideology are like apocalyptic beasts

Synod on the Family also looks into persecution of families by ISIS

Analysis: Christians oppressed for their faith by the Islamic Groups

Only Way to Stop Islamic Terrorism is by Banning Islam

A Monastic Response to Violent Islam

Japan shut down radical Islam entirely…Here’s the simple way they did it.

Shock: The grand lesson of the Paris Jihad

Italian Cardinal Angelo Bagnasco calls on Muslims to publicly condemn ISIS

Paris after the ISIS attacks (Video) & Pope Francis’ Message

At Grand Mosque in Central African Republic, Pope Francis denounces violence perpetrated in the name of religion or God

Islam and French Politics: A Reflection

The Greatest Murder Machine in History


Islam is not a Constitutionally Protected Religion… Here’s why?

Please click this link to read the Article on Islam is not a Constitutionally Protected Religion. Here’s why?

5 Reasons The Qur’an Can Never Co-Exist with the Constitution

Please click this link to read the Article on 5 Reasons the Qur’an can never co-exist with the Constitution

Is Sharia Islamic Law Compatible with the American Constitution?

The top 10 Koran verses that will help you understand ISIS better 

Please click this link to watch the video on Top 10 Koran verses that will help you understand ISIS better

24 Reasons ISIS are wrong: Muslim scholars blast Islamic State

Please click this link to read the article on 24 Reasons ISIS are wrong: Muslim scholars blast Islamic State

Muslims vs. ‘Outlaws of Islam’: Islamic Voices Lead Fight Against Extremists

Report: Only Word for ISIS Atrocities Is Genocide

How You Can Help Stop the Christian Genocide by the ISIS?

ISIS turns Muslim theological tradition on its head: ISIS deviates from mainstream Islam by rejecting scholarly interpretation and religious pluralism

Saints’ bones among rubble of Syrian monastery destroyed by Isil


Bishop Antoine Chbeir Cries Out as ISIS Devastates Syrian Towns

‘Forgive ISIS’: Girl’s dying request to mother after she is burnt alive by militants in her own home

Islam in Crisis – The Decline of Islam is Real

What is the Islamic State? What ISIS really wants?

ISIS’s Anti-Islamic Theology of Rape

Is sex slavery sanctioned in Islam?

 Muslim Activist Says This is Why Islamism is ‘Much More Dangerous Than Nazism’

ISIS Desecrates Saint’s Remains, Bulldozes Monastery – Priest Still Missing

High-Profile Rome Exorcist: ISIS is Satan

German Cardinal Kurt Koch: ISIS is a ‘Satanic Terrorist Group’

UK Cardinal Vincent Nichols: Terrorist need to be stopped – Encouraging use of force against ISIS

A Muslim US President?

Needed: A New Church Policy Toward Islam Part 1

Please click this link to read the Article on Needed: A New Church Policy Toward Islam Part 1

Needed: A New Church Policy Toward Islam Part 2

Please click this link to read the Article Needed: A New Church Policy Toward Islam Part 2

Needed: A New Church Policy Toward Islam Part 3

Please click this link to the Article on Needed: A New Church Policy Toward Islam Part 3

Pope Benedict XVI was right in warning about radical Islam

Does Fr. Dwight Longenecker teach what the Church teaches on Catholic-Muslim relations?

Pope Francis Condemns ‘Homicidal Folly and Senseless Hatred’ in Orlando, Florida, USA


CIA: The Crusades against Muslim Aggression 

Please click this link to watch the video on CIA: The Crusades against Muslim Aggression

The Crusades Were a Reasonable Response to Unchecked Islamic Aggression

The Real History of the Crusades

The Real History of the Crusades – To set the record straight

Four Myths about the Crusades 

4 Myths about the Crusades: In light of beheadings…

Please click this link to read about the Four Myths about the Crusades

ISIS (Islamic State) Flogs the Crusades Myth

Muslim Crusades Started Four Centuries Before the Western Crusades 

Please click this link to read the Article on Muslim Crusades Started Four Centuries Before Western Crusades

Crash Course on the Crusades

Please click this link to read the Article on Crash Course on the Crusades

The Crusades: A Response to Islamic Jihad

Jihad vs Crusades by Bill Warner, PhD

Please click this link to watch the video on Jihad vs Crusades by Bill Warner, PhD

There’s Zero Equivalence Between the Crusades and Muslim Jihad

CIA: The Inquisition during the Medieval, Spanish and Roman Times

Please click this link to watch the video on CIA: The Inquisition during the Medieval, Spanish and Roman Times

Spanish Inquisition was 99% Myth. (BBC)

Obama Compares Catholic Crusades to Islamic ISIS

Please click this link to watch the video on Obama compares Catholic Crusades to Islamic ISIS

Obama at Prayer Breakfast Affirms right to be godless

Please click this link to watch the video on Obama at Prayer Breakfast affirms right to be godless

Watch how Judge Jeanine Just Revealed the Moment She Understood on Obama’s Dark Secret 

Please click this link to watch the video on Judge Jeanine on Obama’s Dark Secret

Forged by War: The Three Battles in the Rise of the Rosary

Please click this link to read the Article on Forged by War: The three battles in the rise of the Rosary

A President, His Muslim Faith, And His Quran… Is It Ok For Him To Lie?

A President, his Muslim Faith and his Quran… Is it Ok for him to lie?

Proclaiming The Gospel in Lebanon: The Mohammad Yamout story

Mario Joseph Testimony , a Muslim Imam Convert to Catholic Church  

Please click this link to watch the video on Mario Joseph Testimony, a Muslim Imam Convert to Catholic Church

Daniel Ali: Muslim Convert to Catholic Christianity

Malaysia Rules Muslim Man Can Convert to Christianity

Muslim Woman Gives Jesus One Week To Prove Himself Before Ending Her Life

From Darkness to Light
As a Muslim imam, Mario Joseph was well-versed in the Koran and in the teachings of the Islamic religion. In fact, it was precisely the Koran that brought him to an encounter with Jesus Christ and with the truth of the Catholic faith. But his conversion did not come without difficulties; as a consequence, he has undergone grave persecution. How has he attained his intense love toward the Church, the Cross and Heaven? He himself tells us in this week’s impacting episode of Changing Tracks.